Morphological analysis
A method that breaks a problem down into its dimensions, lists the options for each and explores the possible combinations in a table.
What it’s for
It helps find solutions nobody would think of at first, because it goes through every combination in an orderly way.
Key elements
Parts and options
Each part of the problem (a parameter) is decided separately and has its own options (values). The table that crosses them is called a morphological box, or Zwicky box.
All the options
For each part, list the alternatives, including the odd ones.
Combinations multiply fast
Each combination, one option per part, is a configuration. Five parts with five options each already give 3,125.
Combinations that fit
Compare the options in pairs and cross out those that can’t go together (cross-consistency assessment). That leaves only a few to study.
An example
A team is designing a reading lamp for a small home.
The table doesn’t invent the idea: it makes you look at combinations that habit skips.
How it’s done
Name the parts of the problem, in columns.
Fill in the options for each part, in rows.
Combine them by choosing one option per column, and assess the best.
Applications in design
When to use it
When a product has several parts that can each be solved in many ways.
Avoid
Using so many parts and options that the combinations become impossible to review.
Don’t fall for it
The table generates ideas, it doesn’t choose them; you still need to test them.
34,560 → 480
What the research says
Extended producer responsibility strategies, before and after crossing out those that couldn’t go together, in a study for the Swedish Ministry of the Environment (Ritchey, 2011).
Single study. It is a case reported by its author, not an experiment. Very few studies compare its ideas with those of other techniques.
Connections
Authors and works
- 1969
Fritz Zwicky
The Caltech astrophysicist used it to explore solutions to technical problems, such as propulsion, and explained it in his book.
- 1998
Tom Ritchey
Explained the Zwicky box and how to discard impossible combinations by comparing the options in pairs; in his account, 99% or more usually drop out.
- 2011
Tom Ritchey
From the Swedish Morphological Society, he gathered more than a hundred client projects over some fifteen years, with models of scenarios, strategies and organizations.
- 2013
John S. Gero, Hao Jiang and Christopher B. Williams
Observed eleven student teams using brainstorming, morphological analysis and TRIZ. The more structured the technique, the more attention they paid to the problem (goals and requirements), especially at the start.
- 2021
Nigel Cross
His handbook of engineering design methods, first published in 1989, teaches it as the morphological chart for generating alternatives.
Sources
Original sources
- Zwicky, F. (1969). Discovery, invention, research through the morphological approach. Macmillan.
- Ritchey, T. (2011). Wicked problems – social messes: Decision support modelling with morphological analysis. Springer. View source: Ritchey, T. (2011)
- Gero, J. S., Jiang, H., & Williams, C. B. (2013). Design cognition differences when using unstructured, partially structured, and structured concept generation creativity techniques. International Journal of Design Creativity and Innovation, 1(4), 196–214. View source: Gero, J. S., Jiang, H., & Williams, C. B. (2013)
Academic reviews
- Ritchey, T. (1998). Fritz Zwicky, “Morphologie” and policy analysis. Ponencia en la 16th EURO Conference on Operational Analysis, Bruselas. View source: Ritchey, T. (1998)
Secondary sources
- Cross, N. (2021). Engineering design methods: Strategies for product design (5th ed.). Wiley. (Obra original publicada en 1989). View source: Cross, N. (2021)
Last reviewed: