Skip to content
APDD
See my library

Approach

Design thinking

A way of tackling open problems with design methods: understanding people, reframing the problem, generating many options and learning by prototyping.

Not to be confused with Double Diamond. Design thinking is how you think; the double diamond is how you order the project’s steps.

Origin
Roots in design research (Simon, 1969; Cross, 1982); Rowe (1987) and Buchanan (1992) in design theory; spread by Brown (2008) and the Stanford d.school

What it’s for

Many problems have no clear statement and no single right solution. Design thinking offers a way to move forward on them without having all the information at the start.

Principles

  • Focus on people

    Understand their needs before proposing anything.

  • Reframe the problem

    Build a new frame from what you learn, instead of solving the brief as it arrived.

  • Balance three criteria

    The idea should be desirable for people, feasible with the technology and viable for whoever sustains it.

  • Learn by prototyping

    Test early and go back if needed.

An example

A clinic gets complaints because the wait feels endless.

Straight to the solution
More chairs are bought for the waiting room. People are still stuck in the room.
Reframe the problem
The team notices that nobody steps away for fear of losing their turn, and tries texting people when their turn is close. People can wait somewhere else.

The first answer accepted the brief (“the room is uncomfortable”); the second changed the question (“why do people have to wait there?”).

How it’s done

  1. Understand and define. Observe people and reframe the problem with what you learn.

  2. Ideate. Many options before settling on one.

  3. Prototype and test. Build something quickly and learn from how people use it. If needed, go back.

Applications in design

  • When to use it

    As a way of thinking through the whole project. To organise it into phases, lean on a map such as the double diamond or the d.school’s five modes.

  • Avoid

    Reducing it to a workshop with sticky notes: without research with real people or critique of what comes out, it’s just brainstorming.

  • Don’t fall for it

    The phases aren’t a linear recipe and don’t guarantee results: go back when a prototype teaches you something new, and check whether the solution worked.

What the research says

50 projects studied over seven years in business, health care and social services led Liedtka (2018) to conclude that its steps help teams see beyond their own assumptions.

Debated evidence. These are observed cases, not experiments. The review by Micheli et al. (2019) clarifies what it is, but its results are still debated.

Authors and works

  1. 1969

    Herbert A. Simon

    Proposed studying design as a science of its own: the science of the artificial.

  2. 1982

    Nigel Cross

    Argued that design has its own way of knowing, distinct from that of the sciences and the humanities.

  3. 1987

    Peter Rowe

    Gave this title to his study of how architects and urban planners design, based on observing them at work.

  4. 1992

    Richard Buchanan

    Explained that design works with “wicked” problems, which can’t be fully defined before being solved.

  5. 2008

    Tim Brown

    Presented it to businesses as a way to match what people need with what technology allows and what a viable business can sustain.

  6. 2011

    Lucy Kimbell

    Distinguished three meanings of the term: designers’ way of thinking, a general theory of design and a resource for organizations to innovate. She criticized how it separates thinking from doing and erases the diversity of practices.

  7. 2011

    Kees Dorst

    Placed its core in design’s abductive reasoning. When only the value sought is known, a new frame for looking at the problem has to be created.

  8. 2017

    Natasha Jen

    In a 99U talk she criticized its reduction to sticky notes and a repeatable formula, and called for evidence and design critique.

  9. Stanford d.school

    Teaches it in five modes: empathize, define, ideate, prototype and test.

  10. 2018

    Jeanne Liedtka

    After studying 50 projects over seven years, described it as a “social technology” that helps teams overcome their biases and habits.

  11. 2019

    Pietro Micheli et al.

    Reviewed the literature and found shared attributes, such as focusing on people, iterating, collaborating across disciplines, visualizing, abductive reasoning and tolerating ambiguity. They warn that the term has so many meanings it risks becoming empty.

Sources

Original sources

Academic reviews

Secondary sources

Last reviewed: