The crystal goblet
The idea that the typography of a text should go unnoticed and serve it: like a clear goblet, its job is to show the content, not itself.
What problem it addresses
It warns against type that shows off at the expense of the message. Graphic design takes from it a criterion for choosing and setting type: first, what the text has to do; then, how it looks.
An example
An illustrative example: the instructions for a medicine, set in two ways.
The words are the same. In the second version the typography almost disappears, and that is what Warde asked of a text meant for reading.
Why it happens
When we read, we look for meaning, not for the shape of each letter.
Type that draws attention gets in the way.
If it goes unnoticed, the content arrives whole.
Applications in design
Use it like this
For long or practical texts, choose familiar typefaces and set them so they read without stumbling.
Avoid
Using an eye-catching typeface for a text people need to read in full.
Don’t fall for it
It doesn’t apply everywhere: on a poster or a cover, type can also be the image, and its voice is part of the message.
8 → 15 min
What the research says
Minutes students estimated for the same exercise routine, written in Arial or in Brush, a hard-to-read typeface (Song and Schwarz, 2008).
Debated evidence. It was a small study, with 20 people. It suggests that type is never fully neutral: it changes how we judge what it says.
Connections
Related to
Authors and works
- 1930
Beatrice Warde
Compared typography to a clear goblet and asked that type for reading not draw attention to itself.
- 1992
Gerard Unger
Disputed that invisible type exists, since nobody chooses one that looks like nothing, and recalled with Zuzana Licko that legibility changes with use.
- 2008
Hyunjin Song and Norbert Schwarz
Showed that instructions in hard-to-read type make a task seem longer and less appealing to do.
Sources
Original sources
- Warde, B. (1955). The crystal goblet, or printing should be invisible. In The crystal goblet: Sixteen essays on typography. Sylvan Press. (Original lecture delivered 1930).
- Unger, G. (1992). Legible? Emigre, 23. (Reeditado en Emigre, 65, 2003). View source: Unger, G. (1992)
- Song, H., & Schwarz, N. (2008). If it's hard to read, it's hard to do: Processing fluency affects effort prediction and motivation. Psychological Science, 19(10), 986–988.
Last reviewed: